As I sat on my screened in porch one morning I heard the varied songs of my feathered friends. When I heard one near me, I attempted to imitate his message in an effort to be friendly. He replied and then I mimicked his sounds again. Back and forth we went. Suddenly I begin to think about the consequences of this mimicry.
The Warbled Thoughts Begin (The Bobwhite)
It all started when I was a kid, with a bobwhite, a form of quail. I was out in the country at my grandfather’s farm and heard the song, “Bob Bob White.” (or so it sounded to me.) Since it sounded so easy to reply, I did. Even with my poor imitation: “Bob Bob White!” I was instantly surprised to hear the echo coming back from that country bird. And back and forth we went. I was surprised at the bird’s tenacity in responding. Finally, I gave up, having other things to do and left him probably wondering, “What a rude bird to lead me on and then stop!”
Now that I am older I whistle back at some birds that have a one note sound and actually get a reply, or are they just humoring or ignoring me. Of course I have no interpreter so I don’t know if they know that only a mortal is answering them instead of a virile male or gorgeous female bird.
There are two pairs, I think, of such birds called Towhees who live near me. I never saw one until last year. But they have a perfect example of this kind of song. I can whistle very much like they “whistle-tweet.”
All of the birds, squirrels and occasional rabbits take their fill of the seeds. They all love the bird seed I put out in front of our porch so Norie, my cat, can daydream about catching one but is prohibited from doing so by the screen.
What are my poor imitations telling those poor birds? What if the warbler is looking for a mate and my whistles are telling him that he’s a real loser of a bird? What if I am making male bird sounds back to a male bird? Is he feeling challenged for his territory? What is he thinking?
A Baby Blue Jay

What if…..?
Worse still, what if I am telling some male bird, ” Come on over Big Boy!? ” So he flies around looking for a gorgeous, feathered female, and he only sees a lumpy, featherless, pale, huge human? What if he is so lovesick and disappointed that he attacks his reflection in a window somewhere and commits bird suicide from frustration. I would be sad if, inadvertently my inaccurate warbling or whistling, caused his desperation and sadness.
Potential Dangers of Mimicked Warbling (The Hawk)

I actually rescued a hawk once. It was an amazing experience.
It is a good thing that I sit in a screened in porch. What if I was toying with the likes of a hawk, making love songs of a tasty sparrow and that hawk was very hungry?? Wouldn’t he be pretty angry or frustrated that there is no food where the bird sounds were being emitted from? He might be pretty frustrated that I led him on with my tasty and sweet sounding chirps.
Sea Gulls
And what about sea gulls at the beach? I would never try to imitate the sounds they make. I could accidentally summon them to think there was a huge cache of food waiting for them. Boy that could be a problem if there were as many as there are in the next picture. Besides you know what gulls do when they fly over you sometimes after eating. It’s not very nice!
I took this picture of thousands of sea gulls who migrated to Wake County in Holly Springs, NC. I was on my way home after working night shift and saw this sight reminiscent of Alfred Hitchcock’s movie “The Birds”!
The Cardinal
The cardinal, also known as the redbird is the state bird of North Carolina, Illinois, Kentucky, Indiana, Ohio, West Virginia, Virginia. The female, as does many other female birds, has a less brighter color, a yellowish brown.
A male cardinal
The House Finch
Another bird which shares the male cardinal’s red color is the male house finch. The male sports the rosy red color, while his mate has a much less distinctive coloring, a grayish brown.

Here is the song of a house finch: https://www.bird-sounds.net/house-finch/
The Eastern Towhee
One bird I just discovered is the Eastern Towhee. I kept looking at what I thought was a robin but had white on it’s wings and body. The Towhee male has several calls. I can imitate one and weakly another, because it sounds like a short whistle starting low and rising up and rising through five notes higher. But it can warble a little too, which I failed miserably at.
Of course actually none of my bird calls would ever be mistaken for the real thing; so there is really not a problem for me. But there are professional bird callers who can tweet with the best tweeters. I wonder what they say or if they know what they are saying to the birds.
If you are interested in learning which bird is which and which one is calling, you can upload a free app on your phone named: “BirdNet.” You can record a bird’s call; then move cursors to “select” the segment you want to analyze. Press analyze and wait. You can “submit” what you recorded and see a picture of the bird with information about them! You can opt to save what you captured too.
Birds add so much beauty and interest to our lives. Take time to look for them, listen to them, watch them as they interact. And feed them wild bird seed when you can. Enjoy your world when you can.
I wanted to tell you how much I enjoyed reading this post but every time I try to open this page my computer says it cannot be found.
Bernadette Laganella http://www.HaddonMusings.com
>
LikeLiked by 1 person
I think I fixed it. Reposted this AM. Please let me know if I fixed it. Thank you!!!
LikeLiked by 1 person
All better😊
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thank you for checking. Hope you enjoyed it.
LikeLike
I often have conversations with a male cardinal on my front porch…now you have me wondering just what exactly I have been promising this poor bird!
LikeLiked by 1 person
There you go! Ever wonder why he keeps coming back for more conversation?? Lol
LikeLiked by 1 person
Delighful post! I too shall be careful out there from now on 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
Maybe I will have helped hundreds of birds from untimely deaths, frustration or rage with this one blog! 😉
LikeLike
What a fascinating insight, I never thought about it like that! By the way, I have nominated you for a Liebster Award to show my appreciation for your blogging efforts 🙂 https://spookymrsgreen.com/2016/05/25/liebster-award-2016/
LikeLiked by 2 people
So glad you like the post. Thank you for the recognition!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Hello
LikeLiked by 1 person
I missed this post before, it’s quite intriguing! I can’t whistle myself so I haven’t tried this, but I’ve heard people say they have whistled to mockingbirds and the birds then imitate them. And also that some black birds and crows will imitate sounds, like for instance, a phone ringing. So, there are indeed lots of questions here as to what kind of harmonies or disruptions might occur to bird communications!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Lol, it was all written in fun by a wacky creative mind. But we do have to wonder what goes on in those little bird brains. LOL. Thank you for commenting. 😉
LikeLiked by 1 person
Dear respected Madam ,
Your post is beautiful.
Regards
Nisthur
LikeLike
Thank you, Sir. I appreciate that!
LikeLike
You are most welcome madam. You are spreading true happiness around get going ….
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thank you, so much! That is my goal in life. I want to help make the world a better place. I appreciate your comments.
LikeLiked by 1 person
😎
LikeLiked by 1 person
I so enjoyed your post, and all the bird calls, really interesting and quite inspiring.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Thank you, Morag. I plan on continuing to learn more songs of more birds. I have a great view from my screened in porch. Thank you for commenting.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I have never tried to mimic a bird song. There is a mockingbird that mimics me when I whistle for my dog. The first time I heard the bird whistle my dog heard it too and looked to see where I was and if I was wanting him to come in. He figured out it wasn’t me whistling for him and now ignores the bird when he whistles. The bird never gives up whistling though…it is funny. The bird also sometimes meows like a cat and does it well.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Wow!! How funny!! I have heart that they could imitate certain sounds but never a human whistle or a cat!! You should do a blog post on that! Thanks for sharing your nifty experiences with me here.
LikeLiked by 1 person
He also can sound like a car alarm. You are welcome.
LikeLiked by 1 person
That’s amazing!!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Nelsapy, Thank you for sharing my blog post. I like the format too!
LikeLike